Retirement / Dividend Investment Strategies / The Dilemma: Withdrawing from a Dividend Portfolio 

The Dilemma: Withdrawing from a Dividend Portfolio 

4 minutes

Image generated with AI

In 2019, my wife and I visited Lake Keowee in South Carolina and found a few acres we purchased with a vague plan to build “sometime” in the future a home that we would eventually transition into for our retirement.  Well, that “sometime” is now, and as a couple who diligently built up a portfolio of dividend-paying stocks over the years, we recently faced a difficult decision.  To build this home meant tapping into the savings we had carefully cultivated through consistent investing and reinvesting of dividends. 

At first, the thought of withdrawing a significant sum from our dividend portfolio was not even an option, I told my wife, “Nope, no way!”  This portfolio represented years of disciplined saving and strategic stock selection aimed at generating a reliable stream of passive income.  Parting with a portion of it felt like undoing all that hard work! 

However, after “much contemplation”, (in reality, discussions with my wife and a friend/mentor – but “much contemplation” makes it seem like I was able to get there on my own 😊), I realized that investing in this home, while a different asset class, was not necessarily a step backward.  Real estate, as many know, can be a powerful wealth-building tool, providing both an enjoyable place to live, and the potential for long-term appreciation. 

Still, the mental hurdle of withdrawing from my dividend portfolio remained.  That’s when I helped launch a game-changing tool with my long-time business partner, Scott Wagoner: Dividends360 to provide current and future income KPI projections. 

Using the D360 Pro version ($40/mo. worth every penny!) to securely link our investment accounts, we could more easily review our remaining portfolio holdings.  Dividends360 allowed me to see precisely how much dividend income I could expect to generate this year and for years going forward.  To my relief, even after withdrawing the necessary funds for the home purchase, the remaining invested assets were projected to produce more than enough dividend income to cover expected expenses. 

This realization was a turning point. Suddenly, the withdrawal didn’t feel like a loss but rather a strategic reallocation of assets. I was simply shifting a portion of my wealth from one income-producing asset (dividend stocks) to another (real estate). 

Of course, the actual process of withdrawing the funds wasn’t without its challenges. There were logistical hurdles to navigate, such as ensuring the proper tax treatment of the withdrawal and coordinating the transfer of funds to the appropriate accounts, but these are topics for future articles! 

Armed with the knowledge that the remaining portfolio would continue to generate sufficient passive income, I was able to approach the transition with confidence and a sense of excitement.  So, you may ask what did I learn?   

1. Diversification is key: While the dividend portfolio served u well, having all the assets tied to equities made the prospect of a major withdrawal daunting.  Diversifying across multiple asset classes provides greater flexibility and peace of mind. 

2. Tools empower informed decisions: Dividends360 was instrumental in helping me understand the long-term implications of the withdrawal.  Having access to such tools can greatly facilitate complex financial decisions. 

3. Embrace change: While it was initially difficult to let go of a portion of the dividend portfolio, embracing change and recognizing the potential of new opportunities (in this case, real estate) ultimately made the transition smoother. 

As we settle into our new home (hopefully within the next 30 days), I can look back on this experience with gratitude for the lessons learned and excitement for the future.  The dividend portfolio, though slightly smaller, continues to generate income, and the new real estate investment represents a promising addition to our overall wealth-building strategy. 

Of course, the real challenge is to now resist the temptation to turn the entire basement into an elaborate man cave.  But maybe I should, don’t you think I earned a little indulgence like a stock ticker scrolling across the wall after all the financial strategizing I had to do!  Who knows, watching those dividend-paying stocks scroll across the wall just might become my favorite new form of entertainment! 

Disclaimer: This blog is for informational purposes only and should not be taken as financial advice. Always consult with a financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Start Your Dividends360
Free Trial Today!

Sign up for free

Subscribe to our D360 Newsletter for investing tips & product insights!